ATA Insights / Construction & CIS Tax

CIS and a PAYE Job at the Same Time: How Your Tax Works in 2026/27

Reviewed: 15 November 2026 | Accounting & Tax Associates Ltd

Working under CIS and PAYE at the same time? Many construction workers are employed through PAYE while also earning self-employed income under the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS).Understanding how these two income sources interact is important when calculating your tax liability, claiming CIS refunds and completing your Self Assessment tax return.

Which year does this guide cover? The tax-rate examples use the 2026/27 tax year (6 April 2026 to 5 April 2027). The upcoming Self Assessment deadlines shown below are for 2025/26. The normal online filing deadline for the 2026/27 return is 31 January 2028.

Can You Be Employed and a CIS Subcontractor at the Same Time?

Yes. HMRC considers the employment status of each engagement separately. Your employer operates PAYE on employment wages; a contractor paying you as a genuinely self-employed subcontractor normally makes CIS deductions from payments for construction work.

You do not register for CIS for work you perform as an employee. Registration is relevant to your self-employed construction work. Contractors usually deduct 20% for a registered subcontractor, or 30% where the subcontractor is not registered or cannot be verified. Some verified subcontractors may qualify for gross payment status.

The status must reflect the real working relationship. If the supposed subcontracting arrangement looks like employment in practice, the correct tax treatment may be different.

How Your Tax Is Collected on Each Job

Your PAYE employment

Your employer deducts Income Tax and Class 1 National Insurance through payroll. A common tax code is 1257L, generally reflecting the standard £12,570 Personal Allowance, but your actual tax code and allowance can differ.

Your CIS subcontracting work

For a registered subcontractor subject to the standard deduction rate, a contractor generally withholds 20% from the amount liable to CIS deductions. This is not necessarily 20% of the full invoice: genuine materials and VAT are normally excluded from the deduction base.

For a sole trader, CIS deductions are advance payments against tax and applicable National Insurance. Your final liability is reconciled in Self Assessment based on your actual business profits and other income.

Why Your CIS Tax Refund Can Be Smaller if You Also Have a PAYE Job

Your Personal Allowance is available against your overall taxable income, not separately against each job. If your employment wages use the entire allowance, additional taxable CIS profits may be subject to Income Tax from the first pound.

For 2026/27 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, where the standard Personal Allowance is available, the basic rate is normally 20% up to £50,270 total taxable earnings before relevant adjustments; the higher rate of 40% generally applies above this point. Scottish rates differ for non-savings income, and higher earners may have a reduced Personal Allowance.

A refund may still arise because CIS deductions are based on payments before you deduct allowable business expenses. Expenses reduce taxable profit, whereas the contractor may already have withheld CIS on the gross labour payment.

Class 4 National Insurance

For 2026/27, standard Class 4 National Insurance rates are 6% on self-employed profits above £12,570 up to £50,270 and 2% on profits above £50,270. PAYE Class 1 National Insurance is separate, although combined-employment and self-employment rules can affect the overall contribution calculation in some cases.

When working under CIS and PAYE at the same time, your employment income and self-employment profits are considered together when calculating your overall Income Tax liability. This can reduce your CIS refund or create additional tax to pay.

Illustration: PAYE salary and CIS income

Assume an individual resident in England has no other taxable income, a standard Personal Allowance and no complicating adjustments:

ItemAmount
PAYE annual salary£30,000
CIS labour payments subject to 20% deduction£14,000
CIS deducted by contractors£2,800
Allowable self-employed expenses£4,000
Taxable CIS profit£10,000
Income Tax attributable to CIS profit (20%)£2,000
Class 4 NI on CIS profit£0
Illustrative excess CIS deductions£800

£2,800 CIS deducted − £2,000 additional Income Tax = £800 potential repayment

Without the PAYE salary, £10,000 self-employment profit could fall within the £12,570 Personal Allowance, making the Income Tax result different. Actual repayments depend on the full return, including PAYE tax, other income, National Insurance, payments on account and any liabilities HMRC offsets.

When Could You Owe Tax Instead of Receiving a CIS Refund?

  • Higher-rate Income Tax: your combined employment income and CIS profit may take you into a higher tax band, although CIS deductions were made at 20%.
  • Income without CIS deductions: some self-employed work falls outside CIS, including many jobs directly for private householders.
  • Insufficient tax through PAYE: an incorrect or temporary tax code may leave additional tax payable.
  • National Insurance or other liabilities: the overall Self Assessment calculation includes more than the CIS deduction credit.

If your Self Assessment bill is under £3,000, you have sufficient PAYE income, and you meet HMRC’s other conditions, you may be able to pay through your tax code. For the 2025/26 return, the online submission deadline for this option is 30 December 2026.

What Should You Do if You Have Both PAYE and CIS Income?

1. Register for Self Assessment where required

People with gross self-employment income over £1,000 normally need to register for Self Assessment, and CIS registration carries its own requirements. If you are already registered, check that HMRC has your self-employment details. For the 2025/26 tax year, the usual registration deadline was 5 October 2026, though HMRC has rules for later notices to file.

2. Gather your records

  • P60 from employment, or P45 where relevant
  • Monthly CIS payment and deduction statements from every contractor
  • Invoices, bank records and receipts for allowable expenses
  • Accurate mileage or vehicle cost records, where applicable

Not all spending is deductible. For example, ordinary clothing is generally not an allowable expense merely because you wear it at work, and home-to-regular-workplace travel may be restricted. Review the facts before claiming costs.

3. Complete the correct return entries

Declare the employment pay and PAYE tax deducted on the employment pages. Report gross self-employment income and eligible expenses on the self-employment pages. Enter CIS deductions suffered in the relevant CIS deductions field. Check all figures against your records.

Upcoming deadlines for 2025/26

ActionDeadline
Online return to request qualifying tax-code collection30 December 2026
Normal online Self Assessment return and balancing payment31 January 2027
Normal online filing deadline for 2026/27 return31 January 2028

Late registration: HMRC may issue a different filing date if you register after 5 October, but the tax payment deadline can still apply. Check your personal notice and payment position.

Making Tax Digital: Does Your PAYE Salary Count?

No. For Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, qualifying income generally means gross self-employment and property income before expenses. PAYE employment income is not included in that threshold calculation.

Qualifying income fromThresholdMTD start date
2024/25 returnOver £50,0006 April 2026
2025/26 returnOver £30,0006 April 2027
2026/27 returnOver £20,0006 April 2028

For example, £35,000 PAYE wages plus £18,000 gross CIS turnover would generally produce £18,000 qualifying income for this purpose, assuming no other self-employment or property income. Individual exemptions and special rules may apply.

Frequently Asked Questions About CIS and PAYE

Do I need a tax return if I have a PAYE job and CIS work?

Usually yes if you are operating as a CIS-registered self-employed subcontractor or otherwise meet Self Assessment requirements. You generally reconcile CIS deductions and claim overpayments through the return.

Why is my CIS refund lower than another subcontractor’s?

Employment income may have already used your Personal Allowance, and combined income can push some profits into a higher-rate band. Expenses, CIS deductions and other tax circumstances also affect the final result.

Can a sole trader claim CIS deductions back during the year?

Normally, CIS deductions suffered by a sole trader are reconciled through Self Assessment after the tax year. Companies follow different rules for recovering CIS deductions.

Will my PAYE employer be told about my CIS work?

HMRC does not ordinarily send employers the details of your separate self-employment income. Your employer may receive an updated PAYE tax code, but that does not ordinarily explain the underlying reason. Check any contractual obligations to your employer separately.

How far back can I claim overpaid tax?

Overpayment relief claims generally have a four-year time limit after the end of the relevant tax year, subject to conditions and exclusions. For 2022/23, that general limit is 5 April 2027. Amendments to existing returns can have different deadlines.

Do I pay Class 4 NI if I already pay Class 1 through employment?

Potentially. Class 4 is normally charged by reference to self-employed profit thresholds, but HMRC takes combined contribution rules into account where relevant. Paying Class 1 does not automatically remove all Class 4 liability.

Need Help With Your CIS and PAYE Tax Return?

Working under CIS while also receiving PAYE wages can make your tax return more complicated. ATA can help reconcile your deduction statements, review allowable expenses and prepare your Self Assessment return accurately.

Accounting & Tax Associates supports tradespeople and construction subcontractors across the UK with CIS tax refunds and Self Assessment services.